Comparison
Cafeity vs Square Loyalty
This is not really a comparison of two loyalty products. Square Loyalty is a feature of Square, and the decision is upstream of loyalty: if you run Square and intend to keep running it, their integration does things no independent product can. If you do not run Square, it is not an option at all. Checked against Square's own pages in August 2026.
It requires Square
Square Loyalty is part of the Square ecosystem. Without their POS and payments, the product does not apply to you.
Points on the transaction
Because it sits inside the till, Square can reward spend and specific items. We stamp visits.
Any till, any processor
Cafeity runs beside whatever you already use, so a loyalty decision never forces a POS migration.
Phone number versus a pass
Square identifies customers by phone number at checkout, with a wallet pass as an option. Ours is a wallet pass first.
The decision is about your till, not your loyalty card
Almost everything that distinguishes Square Loyalty follows from where it lives. It is inside the point of sale, so it sees the basket: what was bought, what it cost, whether the customer bought the thing you are trying to promote. An independent loyalty product sees a scan. If you are already committed to Square, that visibility is genuinely valuable and you should weigh it heavily. If you are not, adopting Square Loyalty means adopting Square, which is a decision about card processing rates, hardware and contracts that dwarfs anything a loyalty programme costs.
What spend-based rewards buy you, and what they cost
Points per pound is more precise than stamps per visit. It rewards your highest-spending customers proportionately, it can promote particular items, and it does not treat a flat white the same as a full breakfast. The cost is comprehension: customers understand ten stamps and a free coffee immediately, and a points balance requires a conversion rate they have to be told. For a café with a simple menu and a repeat habit, stamps usually change behaviour more reliably than points, because the reward is legible at a glance. For a business with a wide price range, points are fairer.
How the customer is identified
Square's own page describes customers typing in their phone number at checkout to earn points automatically, with the option of adding a digital loyalty pass to Apple Wallet. Typing a number is frictionless to set up and slower at the counter, and it means your loyalty scheme is attached to a phone number your customer has to remember to give. A wallet pass is a card they can see, with a balance on it and your name on it, which is a small but real difference in how present the programme is between visits.
What you are not tied to
The argument for an independent product is simply that a loyalty programme should not decide your payments. If you change till, change processor, add a second site running different hardware, or take a card machine to a market, your customers' cards keep working because the programme never lived inside the till. That also means you are not exposed to a change in your POS provider's pricing or their decision to move a feature into a higher bundle.
Where Square Loyalty is the better choice
If you already run Square, do not want another supplier, and value the till integration, use theirs. Automatic accrual with no scan at all is a real advantage at a busy counter, spend-based rewards are more precise than stamps, and one bill from one vendor has genuine administrative value. Their trial is 30 days. We would rather say that plainly than pretend an independent product wins on every axis.
A note on price
We are not quoting a figure for Square Loyalty because Square does not publish a standalone monthly price on the pages we checked — loyalty appears inside their bundled plans, and the cost depends on which plan and, historically, on how many loyalty visits you have in a month. That is exactly the kind of number that goes stale and misleads, so ask Square directly for a figure at your visit volume. Cafeity is $25 a month for one café, and the rate per location falls as you add sites.
Common questions
- Can I use Square Loyalty without Square POS?
- No. It is part of Square's ecosystem and assumes their point of sale and payments. If you use another till, an independent loyalty product is the only route.
- Is stamps or points better for a café?
- Stamps, usually. Ten stamps and a free coffee is understood instantly, and comprehension is most of what makes a scheme change behaviour. Points are fairer where your prices vary widely.
- Does Cafeity integrate with my POS?
- It runs alongside it rather than inside it — staff scan the customer's code on a phone. That is why it works with any till, and also why it cannot reward specific items the way a POS-native scheme can.
- What does Square Loyalty cost?
- Square does not publish a standalone monthly price on its main pricing pages; loyalty sits within its bundled plans and has historically been tiered by monthly loyalty visits. Ask them for a figure at your volume rather than trusting a number quoted second-hand.
Keep reading
Cafeity vs Loopy Loyalty
An honest comparison of Cafeity and Loopy Loyalty: per-location pricing against fixed plans, staff limits, card designs, and where Loopy is the better choice.
Standalone loyalty vs your POS loyalty module
Your till probably offers a loyalty add-on. Sometimes that is the right answer. Here is how to tell whether it is yours.
Cafeity vs Stamp Me
An honest comparison of Cafeity and Stamp Me: published pricing, multi-site support, SMS and tap-to-stamp hardware, and where Stamp Me is the better fit.
Put your loyalty card in your customers’ pockets
Publish a branded card in about five minutes. 14-day free trial, cancel any time.